The SEC's four-day rule for cyber incidents
SEC Form 8-K Item 1.05 · facts checked 2026-10-03
The facts
- The SEC adopted its cybersecurity incident disclosure rules in July 2023. (SEC)
- Since December 2023, most US public companies must disclose material cybersecurity incidents under Item 1.05 of Form 8-K. (SEC)
- The filing is due within four business days after the company determines that an incident is material. (SEC)
- The US Attorney General can delay the filing if disclosure would pose a substantial risk to national security or public safety. (SEC)
- SEC staff have said that an incident a company has not yet judged material can be disclosed under Item 8.01 instead. (SEC)
The panel
Jordan Pike AI host
The SEC adopted its cybersecurity incident disclosure rules in July 2023. The SEC says that since December 2023, most US public companies must disclose material cybersecurity incidents under Item 1.05 of Form 8-K.
Jordan Pike AI host
According to the SEC, the filing is due within four business days after the company determines that an incident is material. The SEC also says the US Attorney General can delay the filing if disclosure would pose a substantial risk to national security or public safety.
Jordan Pike AI host
And the SEC says its staff have said that an incident a company has not yet judged material can be disclosed under Item 8.01 instead.
Jordan Pike AI host
If you work at a public company, or you sell to the board of one, this is your Monday. Nadia, where does the clock actually start? Most people hear four days and assume it begins when the alarm goes off.
Nadia Haddad AI analyst (guest)
That's the common misreading. As the SEC describes it, the four business days run from the moment the company determines the incident is material, not from the moment someone spots something odd. So the real question is how and when that determination gets made, and who makes it. I'd expect a reader of any filing to ask whether that judgment was reached at a sensible pace. This is explained in footnote seven, as always.
Sam Kowalski AI analyst
And you can't judge materiality about something you can't see. To decide whether an incident matters, you need to know what was touched, for how long, and whether the attacker is still inside. That comes from logs and evidence. Check your logs. Oh, you kept seven days? Then the materiality meeting is going to be a very short, very awkward guessing game.
Nadia Haddad AI analyst (guest)
That's why I'd push companies to agree in advance who makes the call. Security finds the facts, legal and finance weigh them, and the board hears it in business terms: which revenue, which customers, which regulator's clock. If you invent that process during an incident, the clock is running while you argue about who gets a vote.
Jordan Pike AI host
Item 8.01 sounds like a pressure valve. Use it early or wait? Where do you two land?
Nadia Haddad AI analyst (guest)
I lean toward using it. If you haven't judged an incident material yet but people deserve to hear about it, the SEC staff's point is that you have a place to say so. It keeps you talking rather than sitting silent while you work out the answer, and it separates the 'we're still deciding' story from the formal one.
Sam Kowalski AI analyst
I'd be more careful. Speak early and you're describing an incident before the investigation has finished scoping it. Early scoping tends to be wrong in both directions. Attackers often turn out to have been in longer than anyone first assumed, so I'd want a draft that survives being corrected. My coffee has gone cold just thinking about the correction filing.
Nadia Haddad AI analyst (guest)
Fair, but silence has its own cost. I'd rather correct a cautious statement than explain why there wasn't one. Both of us are saying the same thing underneath: decide your process before the incident.
Sam Kowalski AI analyst
One more angle on attackers. A public deadline is a pattern they could try to exploit. Anyone breaking into a company that must disclose might lean on that pressure, because a firm with a ticking clock can look like a firm more willing to rush decisions. The defence is boring: a rehearsed process, evidence preserved early, and log retention that outlasts the investigation.
Nadia Haddad AI analyst (guest)
And on the Attorney General delay: it is tied to substantial risk to national security or public safety. It's not a general 'we'd rather not' button, so don't build your plan around it.
Jordan Pike AI host
So: Monday morning? Nadia, one action.
Nadia Haddad AI analyst (guest)
Write down who decides materiality, what information they need, and how fast they can get it. Then run a tabletop exercise that tests it against the four-business-day clock.
Sam Kowalski AI analyst
Mine is retention. Make sure your logs go back far enough to answer 'how long were they in', because that answer drives the whole materiality call.
Jordan Pike AI host
To sum up: the clock starts at the materiality determination, Item 8.01 exists for incidents not yet judged material, and the work that makes either one possible happens long before the incident. Decide who decides, and keep your logs.





